Hello dear
Welcome to New York Pizza
New York Pizza in Hayward, CA offers a unique pizza experience with a range of specials like the Everyday Special and Triple Treat Special. Customers praise the beef pepperoni option for non-pork eaters and the fresh, quality toppings. The family-owned business has maintained its reputation for decades, with customers driving long distances for a taste of their authentic New York-style pizza. The friendly staff, consistent quality, and variety of options make this pizza joint a must-visit for pizza lovers in the Bay Area. The outdoor seating potential and potential for expansion add to the allure of this hidden gem.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
King Kong Pizza Deal
Two Pizza Deal
Pizza, Wings and Soda Special
Best Deal
About
New York Pizza
Known for its delectable pizzas, New York Pizza offers a wide range of menu items that cater to every pizza lover's craving. From classic favorites like the NY Special Pizza with up to 17 toppings to unique creations like the King Kong Pizza, there is something for everyone to enjoy.
But it's not just the pizzas that make New York Pizza stand out. The appetizers, like the Cheesy Bacon Breadsticks and Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, are perfect for starting your meal off right. And their fresh salads, like the Caesar Salad and New York Salad, provide a refreshing and healthy option.
What sets New York Pizza apart is not only the quality of their food but also their exceptional customer service. Customers rave about the friendly staff and the warm atmosphere inside the restaurant. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or getting delivery, you can always expect top-notch service.
And let's not forget about the great deals and specials that New York Pizza offers. The Best Deal, Everyday Special, and Triple Treat are just a few of the value-packed options that will satisfy your hunger without breaking the bank.
After reading glowing reviews from customers like Myra A., Mark J., and Susan L., it's clear that New York Pizza has a loyal following who appreciate the consistent quality and flavor of their dishes. If you're in the Hayward area and craving some delicious pizza, make sure to stop by New York Pizza for an unforgettable dining experience.
Join us as we dive deeper into the world of New York Pizza and uncover the secrets behind their mouth-watering dishes. We promise you won't be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Amazingg Pizza place, loved it!! Just the way I like it! Great staff and great customer service. Take away service and delivery available. Inside a liquor store, great bright inside. ”
“ Pizza is really good. I love how they offer beef pepperoni since I don't eat pork. Everyone's really nice here and there and always consistent. ”
“ Bay Area, listen up!!!!! Stop playing with me.... The best New York Pizza you're ever going to get, period point blank, is in my HOMETOWN HAYWARD! A st New York pizza has been putting it down since I was 19 yrs old, lol. 21 years later and they are still putting it down. The original New York Pizza aside from NY! I know I know, some will argue and say Tennyson New York pizza was the original but to me these guys are the original bc they have the best tasting toppings and they've been consistent for decades. You get what you pay for no doubt. While everyone else is being cheap with their toppings super skimpy, This place gives you exactly what you ask for. I drove literally an hour from the South Bay just to pick up a pizza from Hayward. Shame on the rest of you pizza parlors! None of you guys are even competing with these guys. Even funnier, they're under new ownership. Paul's family sold it, but guess what? The new owners didn't change a thing. The pizza is still amazing. Especially their ground beef and beef pepperoni. My fiance and I are Muslim, I don't eat pork, so this place has everything beef, which is so nice since everyone else always has pork. They have great customer service, and the people running it are sweethearts. I'm going to post close-up pictures of the pizza. I'm never going to go anywhere else when craving pizza. I guess I'm going to have to drive an hour to get to my old school pizza joint. Thanks, guys, for keeping it original. See you guys again. ”
“ I have a tip for you. The phone number appears to be 510-5 82-3333. The one on the wall on the side of the building does not answer. You can order pizza by the slice and they have a veggie pizza for $5.99. Basically, they make it fresh. So, order ahead of time even for a slice. Then go over to the dollar store. Grab a 16 fluid ounce Coca-Cola including 0 cal for $1.25. Put in for a super lotto quick pick because you just saved yourself over a dollar in soda price at the liquor store. The crust was exceptional. I'd come here again. It's a shame that the outdoor seating in the back is not used for café seating as a restaurant. We could use an outdoor seating spot like this as a restaurant café with this good parking. All these new developments happening and this outdoor seating café is underutilized as a liquor store and a pizza place in the back. No seating all pick up and delivery. Hayward city, see if you can talk him into making this a café. Offer them a great deal on grants for upgrading this brick building into something that's more earthquake. Friendly if that's the problem. It's a great addition to the urban scene downtown. Lots of potential! Higher return than the little café at the library. And turn the Lucky into a Trader Joe's! ”
“ We love the pizza here! Consistently solid. And everyone who works here is really nice! ”
“ I don't get all the negative reviews. This place is our default pizza place, which means we order here quite a bit. We've never had a problem. They are always on time or early and they have yet to mess up an order. The pizza itself is fantastic. I really like my "new england" pizza and this is the closest out here I"ve seen in the bay area. The salads are pretty solid as well. I would not recommend actually eating there though- this is more of a pickup or delivery place than an eat in one. ”
